Randy Roth, The Charming Thief And Murderer Who Killed At Least One Of His Wives To Claim Life Insurance

No just one batted an eye when Randy Roth’s next wife fell off a cliff in 1981, but the death of his fourth spouse in 1991 — together with the massive insurance coverage policy he experienced on her existence — aroused suspicion.

Randy Roth was married four situations. Two of people marriages ended with his wife’s loss of life.

Initially was his next wife Janis Roth, who fell to her death during a hike at Beacon Rock. The next was his fourth wife Cynthia Baumgartner Roth, who drowned in Lake Sammamish — the quite exact same lake in which Ted Bundy experienced kidnapped two females a number of yrs ahead of.

In both of those instances, Roth was the only witness. In each scenarios, he had the bodies cremated as immediately as achievable.

At very first, it seemed as if Roth may perhaps have been an unlucky victim of tragedy, doomed endlessly to be a one father. But law enforcement shortly noticed that Roth was quick to dollars in on his fourth wife’s significant life insurance policies coverage. When they questioned him about the occasions that led to Cynthia’s loss of life, holes in Roth’s tale emerged, and became tricky to ignore.

Experienced Roth murdered his spouse? Investigators understood it would be tough to show, but as they dug further into his earlier, the picture of the real Randy Roth began to consider form. Roth experienced regularly tried to defraud insurance businesses and steal from previous employers, for illustration, and his way of living was much far more lavish than his claimed annual revenue could have delivered for.

Shortly more than enough, his motive grew to become clear: Roth had killed his spouse Cynthia to collect on her everyday living insurance — and he may well really perfectly have accomplished the exact to Janis.

David And Randy Roth, The Killer Brothers

Born on Dec. 26, 1954, Randy Roth was one of five youngsters born to Gordon and Lizabeth Roth. The household moved to Washington quickly right after Roth’s start, and he grew up there.

All through his existence, Roth bonded with his father more than his mom, and right after his parents’ divorce, he correctly minimize his mom out of his everyday living fully.

Lizabeth Roth would later on express that Gordon experienced been a strict and abusive father who exclusively had discouraged his sons from demonstrating any feelings, which he regarded as to be far too female.

“Randy and his brother had been introduced up by their father, who didn’t enable them to present emotion,” she told the Seatle Times, conveying that “He (Randy Roth) was reprimanded for it. Which is just the way he was brought up.”

Regretably, this experienced a lasting impact on the two Randy and David.

As crime author Ann Rule comprehensive in her book A Rose for Her Grave, David and Randy Roth the two lacked empathy as grown ups — and just about every grew to become a killer.

On Aug. 13, 1977, 20-12 months-previous David Roth was arrested for possession of cannabis soon after remaining stopped for a slight targeted traffic violation in the small hamlet of Gold Bar in Snohomish County, Washington. When hunting the auto, police also observed a rifle and ammunition.

A working day later, a few accumulating blackberries found the body of a young girl who experienced been strangled and shot 7 situations. At very first, these seemed like unrelated situations.

However, a several days later on, a pal of David Roth’s walked into the Snohomish County Sheriff’s Place of work with an alarming bit of news: David Roth experienced confessed to him that he murdered the female. She was hitchhiking around the Boeing Company’s Everett plant when David Roth noticed her and picked her up. They purchased some beer and went to the woods to consume it.

David Roth informed his good friend that he attempted to have sex with the female then, but she turned down him. In retaliation, he strangled her with an elastic twine, took a rifle from the trunk of his automobile, and shot her.

The Seattle Moments reports that David was thanks to show up in courtroom on Aug. 22 for a pre-sentencing job interview on a cannabis possession cost, but he in no way confirmed. He was on the run for much more than a year right until he was arrested on Jan. 18, 1979 in Port Orchard, Washington.

David Roth put in 26 decades in prison before getting introduced in 2005. He died of most cancers on Aug. 9, 2015 — nearly exactly 38 many years to the day immediately after he killed the hitchhiking lady. Five years later, The News Tribune documented, she was ultimately determined with DNA testing. Her name was Elizabeth Ann Roberts.

“Randy Roth experienced informed a quantity of girls about his brother, ‘the murderer,’” Rule wrote. “This was 1 of Randy’s stories that appeared to be real.”

The working day David Roth was sentenced to lifetime in prison, in February 1980, Randy was 25. That identical thirty day period, Randy Roth and his initially spouse, Donna Sanchez, divorced. Prior to the wintertime was in excess of, Roth satisfied Janis Miranda, and in a yr they ended up married.

Then, on Nov. 27, 1981, Janis Miranda Roth fell to her death off Beacon Rock.

Janis Miranda And Randy Roth’s Fateful Whirlwind Romance

Randy Roth fulfilled Janis Miranda at a Mother and father With no Associates social. Roth experienced experienced a son with his initial wife, Donna Sanchez, in 1977, a boy named Greg, and Roth applied his standing as a father to his edge. Janis also experienced a boy or girl, a daughter named Jalina, from an previously relationship.

“Sometimes Janis leapt with no contemplating,” Rule wrote, “making conclusions based on emotions rather than on widespread feeling. She seemed to transform her intellect as typically as she improved her clothes. The a single thing she was totally steadfast about was her daughter. Jalina usually arrived to start with. Janis would have supplied up her lifetime for her minor female.”

Roth appealed to this factor of Janis, telling her about Greg and showing her a photo of him that he held with him usually. They linked, Janis felt, over their mutual really like for their very own kids. To her it appeared that Randy Roth was diverse from other men who experienced occur into her life, so when he asked if he may get in touch with her, she agreed with enthusiasm.

“The far more time she invested with Randy, the a lot more she thanked her fortunate stars,” Rule wrote. “All he appeared to care about was her pleasure. She experienced under no circumstances known any person like that ahead of.”

Roth showered her with like and passion at 1st, but that speedily faded soon after they married. He was closed off, inattentive — even their sex daily life quickly died absent.

Not very long just after they returned from their honeymoon, Janis Roth’s car was stolen, and Roth collected the insurance policy revenue. He certain his wife to stop her occupation and with each other, in September 1981, they bought $100,000 in whole lifetime insurance policies.

The insurance policy took influence on Nov. 7 of that calendar year.

3 weeks afterwards, Randy Roth prompt the two go on a hiking trip to Beacon Rock — and Janis Miranda Roth was under no circumstances viewed alive once again. Roth, the sole witness to his wife’s dying, claimed that she fell though they ended up hiking.

Within just a handful of months, he had collected the $100,000 in life coverage proceeds.

He was by no means billed with Janis’ murder.

The Murder Of Cynthia Roth

By the spring of 1990, Randy Roth experienced after again been married and divorced, this time to a female named Donna Clift, one more one mother, and tried to defraud various insurance providers.

A timeline of the situations from Radford University’s Office of Psychology reveals that Roth was also fired from two different positions — one particular at Vitamilk, the other at Cascade Ford — submitted for unemployment added benefits, and described a theft at his residence totaling $57,000 in losses.

Then, he achieved Cynthia “Cindy” Baumgartner. Like the other females in his lifestyle, Cindy was a one mom. She had two little ones, Tyson and Rylie. In just a several months, Roth and Cindy were being married, and he and Greg had moved into Cindy’s residence in South Everett.

Notably, Rule wrote, “Cindy was far far better proven fiscally than Randy was.”

In early January 1991, Randy and Cindy Roth bought extra lifetime insurance — $385,000 well worth, in accordance to the Seattle Situations. She even adjusted the beneficiary of her lifetime coverage from her sons to Roth, as he claimed he experienced manufactured her the beneficiary of his. This was, on the other hand, a lie.

But just as he had accomplished with Janis, Roth’s mind-set toward his new wife promptly improved. She commenced to grow to be unhappy in their relationship, as pals noted, and even wrote in a journal that she felt Roth hated nearly every little thing about her.

In a single journal entry, she wrote:

Randy hates the swamp that Cindy made him transfer to.

Randy hates Cindy’s residence.

Randy hates Cindy’s issues

Randy hates Cindy’s income.

Randy hates Cindy’s impartial character.

Then, on July 23, 1991, Roth instructed they choose a household trip to Lake Sammamish. He remaining the little ones to play on their own and took a raft out on to the lake with his spouse.

When he returned, she was useless. Roth claimed that a speedboat wake experienced capsized their raft and that Cynthia drowned as a final result.

Roth wasted no time in trying to obtain on Cindy’s lifetime insurance, both. And only a mere two times immediately after her demise, Roth emptied out her safe and sound deposit box, which contained her will and jewellery from her ex-partner.

Meanwhile, in early August, a lady named Kristina Baker notified law enforcement that she experienced found Roth and Cindy out on their raft — and that it had not flipped above, as he claimed.

Roth was arrested for murder on Oct. 9, 1991, with his demo getting place from January to April 1992. He was finally found responsible of the murder of Cynthia Baumgartner Roth and sentenced to 55 decades in jail at the Washington State Penitentiary where he was as soon as all over again reunited with his brother, David.

And nevertheless Randy Roth was never charged with the murder of Janis Miranda Roth, several persons consider that he killed her to collect on her daily life insurance coverage, just as he had accomplished with Cynthia.

---

Just after studying the disturbing story of Randy Roth, read through about a different wicked killer, Shelly Knotek, the serial killer mother who brutalized her have family. Then, examine the tale of Larry Gene Bell, the killer who stunned even “Mindhunter” John Douglas.